Mr Musaab YassinCommon Questions

Common Questions · No. 51

Your first appointment

Two questions stop more men booking than any symptom does: will there be a rectal examination, and will I end up with a catheter.

By Mr Musaab Yassin, Consultant Urological Surgeon & Andrologist. Oxford and central London.

For many men, the biggest barrier to booking a urology appointment is not the urinary symptom itself. It is uncertainty about what the appointment will involve.

Two fears come up repeatedly:

  • “Will they do a rectal examination?”
  • “Will they put in a catheter?”

The evidence-based reality is usually much less dramatic. A first appointment for male urinary symptoms is primarily an assessment: understanding the symptoms, checking for warning signs and performing a small number of targeted tests.1, 2

A digital rectal examination may be useful in some situations. A catheter is not routinely inserted simply because you have attended urology clinic.

What normally happens first?

The consultation usually begins with questions about:

  • weak stream;
  • hesitancy;
  • straining;
  • stopping and starting;
  • incomplete emptying;
  • frequency;
  • urgency;
  • leakage;
  • nocturia;
  • infections;
  • blood in the urine;
  • medicines;
  • previous urological treatment;
  • sexual function where relevant.

European guideline frameworks emphasise a practical initial assessment combining history, physical examination, symptom scores, urine testing and selected objective measurements.1, 2

Will I have to complete a questionnaire?

Often, yes.

The International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS) is a common seven-question questionnaire covering urinary symptoms plus a quality-of-life question.

It does not diagnose the cause. Its purpose is to quantify how severe and bothersome the symptoms are and provide a baseline against which treatment can later be judged.

What is uroflowmetry?

Uroflowmetry is a non-invasive test that measures how quickly urine flows.

You urinate into a specialised device, usually in privacy. The machine records the flow pattern and maximum urinary flow rate (Qmax).

It can help show whether flow is reduced, but a low flow does not by itself prove that the prostate is obstructing. Bladder contraction also affects flow.

Guideline-based assessment commonly includes uroflowmetry when objective assessment of male LUTS is needed.1, 2

What is a post-void residual scan?

After you urinate, a small ultrasound scanner is placed over the lower abdomen to estimate how much urine remains in the bladder.

This is called the post-void residual (PVR).

It is painless and does not require a tube to be passed into the bladder.

A raised residual can occur because of obstruction, reduced bladder contraction or both. It may influence whether further tests are needed.

Will I have a digital rectal examination?

Possibly—but not because every urology visit requires one.

A digital rectal examination (DRE) allows the clinician to feel the back surface of the prostate through the rectal wall. It can provide information about prostate size, consistency, tenderness and obvious irregularity.

The 2015 EAU assessment guideline included DRE within the physical examination of men with LUTS.1 Contemporary practice increasingly places DRE in the context of the specific clinical question rather than treating it as a stand-alone cancer screening test.

If a DRE is proposed, the clinician should explain why it is being recommended and what information it is expected to add.

Does a rectal examination diagnose prostate cancer?

No.

A DRE cannot reliably rule prostate cancer in or out on its own. A normal-feeling prostate does not guarantee that cancer is absent, and an abnormal-feeling prostate is not automatically cancer.

Modern prostate-cancer assessment may also involve PSA testing, MRI and risk-based decision-making.

The role of DRE is therefore supportive and contextual, not definitive.

Why are men so worried about DRE?

The concern is well documented.

A systematic review of 60 qualitative studies involving 3,029 men across eight countries examined men's perspectives on PSA testing and DRE.4 Themes included bodily intrusion, threats to masculinity, embarrassment, uncertainty and fear.4

Those concerns should not be trivialised. Good clinical practice is to explain the examination, obtain consent, preserve privacy and offer a chaperone according to local policy and patient preference.

Can I say no to a rectal examination?

Yes. An intimate examination requires consent.

If you are uncertain, it is entirely reasonable to ask:

  • Why do you recommend it?
  • What information will it provide?
  • Will the result change what happens next?
  • Is there an alternative way to answer the same question?

Declining an examination may sometimes limit the information available, but the decision should be informed rather than assumed.

And you can ask for a chaperone

You should not have to raise this yourself, but it is worth knowing where the evidence sits, because clinics vary.

Across the published surveys, 73 to 88% of urology patients thought a chaperone should be offered — and in one study 25.6% said they would not feel comfortable asking for one if it were not offered.5 That is the whole problem in a sentence: the people most likely to want a chaperone are the least likely to request one.

A 2025 survey of UK urology outpatients found that patients identify genital examination, rectal examination and catheterisation as the sensitive ones, but that only a minority actually wanted a chaperone present.6 So the point is not that everyone needs one. It is that being offered the choice matters more than what most people choose.

The same applies to who else is in the room. Asking first, introducing everyone present, explaining each person's role and seeking agreement for a trainee or observer are what patients consistently say improves the experience.7 You may also ask for any part of an examination to stop at any point, and that request does not need to be justified.

Preparation genuinely reduces the anxiety

This is one of the few things in this field with randomised evidence behind it.

In a randomised trial before urodynamics, a brochure plus a short video lowered expected pain and anxiety and improved both readiness and satisfaction compared with routine information alone.8 A second randomised study found that adding an animated explanation to the standard verbal and written information reduced pre-test anxiety further still.9

The practical version: ask what the test involves before the day, not on the couch.

Will I have a catheter inserted?

Usually not.

A urinary catheter is a soft tube passed through the urethra into the bladder to drain urine. Routine evidence-based LUTS assessment focuses on history, urine testing, physical examination, flow measurement and post-void residual—not automatic catheterisation.1, 2

A catheter is used when there is a specific clinical need.

When might a catheter actually be needed?

Examples include:

  • acute urinary retention—being unable to pass urine;
  • severe chronic retention when bladder drainage is required;
  • certain operations or procedures;
  • selected diagnostic situations;
  • monitoring in particular acute clinical circumstances.

If you are passing urine and a bladder scan shows an acceptable residual, there is no routine reason to insert a catheter merely because you have urinary symptoms.

What if the bladder scan shows a large residual?

A raised residual does not automatically mean immediate catheterisation.

The clinician will consider:

  • how much urine remains;
  • whether the result is persistent;
  • kidney function;
  • recurrent infection;
  • bladder symptoms;
  • whether there is hydronephrosis or another complication;
  • whether the patient can still void effectively.

Some men require drainage. Others need further assessment without immediate catheterisation.

The number itself is interpreted in clinical context.

Will I have a cystoscopy at the first appointment?

Not routinely for uncomplicated LUTS.

A flexible cystoscopy is a small camera passed through the urethra to inspect the urethra and bladder. It may be recommended when there is:

  • blood in the urine;
  • suspected urethral narrowing;
  • recurrent infection;
  • suspected bladder pathology;
  • a need to understand anatomy before certain procedures.

The EAU assessment guideline explicitly recommends cystoscopy selectively rather than as a universal investigation for male LUTS.1

What about urodynamics?

Formal urodynamic testing measures bladder pressure and urinary flow in more detail. It is not routinely needed for every man with straightforward LUTS.1, 2

It is generally reserved for situations in which understanding bladder function is likely to change treatment—for example, where the distinction between obstruction and weak bladder contraction is uncertain.

Are these tests tolerable?

Most first-line tests are non-invasive. More invasive tests can cause temporary discomfort or embarrassment, but patient-preference research suggests many men accept investigations when they understand how the information will improve treatment decisions.3

A systematic review of 29 studies involving 9,235 patients found that men's preferences are strongly influenced by the expected benefits, risks and side effects of both testing and treatment.3

Explanation therefore matters. A test feels very different when the patient knows what question it is answering.

What happens at my clinic

A first consultation is booked for at least twenty minutes, and you should allow up to an hour if a flow test, bladder scan, blood or urine test is likely on the day — the point being that one visit should end in a plan rather than a list of things to come back for.

An intimate examination is always explained first, consent is asked for, and a chaperone is offered every time, whether or not you think you want one. If you would rather not have a rectal examination, say so; I will tell you what that means for the information available, and we will work with what we have.

You will not have a catheter passed because you attended a clinic. You will have one only if you cannot empty your bladder, or if a procedure requires it, and in either case it will be discussed before it happens.

How can I prepare for the appointment?

Useful preparation may include:

  • bring an up-to-date medication list;
  • bring previous urine-culture results if recurrent infection is a problem;
  • complete any symptom questionnaire in advance;
  • if nocturia is important, consider a two- or three-day bladder diary if the clinic has requested one;
  • arrive with a comfortably full bladder if uroflowmetry may be performed;
  • write down the two or three questions that matter most to you.

And it is perfectly reasonable to say at the beginning:

“Could you explain before any intimate examination or procedure what you are recommending and why?”

How strong is the evidence?

The assessment pathway is supported by major European urology guidelines.1, 2

Patient-preference evidence is systematic-review based but generally low to moderate certainty.3

Evidence on attitudes to DRE comes mainly from qualitative studies, which are appropriate for understanding embarrassment and perceptions but do not quantify the clinical value of DRE.4

Bottom line

A first urology appointment is usually a diagnostic conversation plus targeted assessment, not a procedure session.

You may be asked for a urine sample, complete a symptom questionnaire, perform a flow test and have a painless bladder scan.1, 2

A rectal examination may be suggested if it is clinically useful, and should be explained and consented to. A catheter is not routinely inserted unless there is a specific reason such as urinary retention or a procedure.

Knowing that beforehand can remove an unnecessary barrier to seeking help.

Most of what men dread about a first urology appointment does not happen. You will be asked questions, you will probably pass urine into a machine, and you will have a painless scan of your bladder. If I think a rectal examination would add something, I will explain why before I suggest it, offer a chaperone, and accept your answer either way. You are allowed to ask me to stop at any point, and nothing is done to you that has not been explained first.

If this sounds like you

A first consultation is £295, and follow-up £190. It usually runs at least twenty minutes; allow up to an hour if you are likely to need a flow test, scan, or blood or urine test on the day. You do not need a referral to book privately, and you are under no obligation to proceed with anything.

Send an enquiry · Symptom questionnaire · Compare the treatments, with the evidence

The 9 studies behind this page▾
  1. Gratzke C, Bachmann A, Descazeaud A, et al. EAU Guidelines on the Assessment of Non-neurogenic Male Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms including Benign Prostatic Obstruction. European Urology. 2015;67:1099–1109. doi:10.1016/j.eururo.2014.12.038
  2. Gravas S, Gacci M, Gratzke C, et al. Summary Paper on the 2023 European Association of Urology Guidelines on the Management of Non-neurogenic Male Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms. European Urology. 2023. doi:10.1016/j.eururo.2023.04.008
  3. Malde S, Umbach R, Wheeler J, et al. A Systematic Review of Patients' Values, Preferences, and Expectations for the Diagnosis and Treatment of Male Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms. European Urology. 2021. 29 studies; 9,235 patients. doi:10.1016/j.eururo.2020.12.019
  4. James LJ, Wong G, Craig J, et al. Men’s perspectives of prostate cancer screening: A systematic review of qualitative studies. PLoS ONE. 2017;12. 60 studies; 3,029 men. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0188258
  5. Mitra T, Koerber NK, Shah H, et al. Chaperones utilization in clinical practice: intimate and sensitive physical examination best practice strategies and concepts in modern urological medicine. Health Psychology Research. 2022;10(4):38954. doi:10.52965/001c.38954
  6. George M, Pearce I, Gkentzis A, Stasinou T. Chaperones in urology clinic: an updated survey of patient perspectives and preferences in the outpatient setting in the United Kingdom. Postgraduate Medical Journal. 2025. doi:10.1093/postmj/qgaf085
  7. Selman L, Ochieng CA, Lewis A, Drake M, Horwood J. Recommendations for conducting invasive urodynamics for men with lower urinary tract symptoms: qualitative interview findings from a large randomized controlled trial (UPSTREAM). Neurourology and Urodynamics. 2018;38:320–9. doi:10.1002/nau.23855
  8. Ozden E, Iyigun E, Bedir S. The effect of different education methods before invasive urodynamics on patients' anxiety, pain, readiness and satisfaction levels: randomized controlled clinical trial. Pain Management Nursing. 2024. doi:10.1016/j.pmn.2024.05.003
  9. Şahin M, Gürbüz M, Savun M, et al. Effect of supplementary video information on patient anxiety before urodynamic testing: a randomized controlled study. International Neurourology Journal. 2025;29:135–41. doi:10.5213/inj.2550038.019

Mr Musaab Yassin is a Consultant Urological Surgeon and Andrologist practising in Oxford and central London. FRCS (Urol). GMC 6118378. Reviewed August 2026.

This page gives general information and does not replace an individual assessment. Figures quoted come from published research and describe groups of patients rather than any one person — your own history, anatomy and priorities change what they mean for you.